The rec.music.beatles.moderated charter
From bcm.tmc.edu!cs.utexas.edu!news.sprintlink.net!news-peer.sprintlink.net!uunet!bounce-back Thu Oct 31 09:08:56 CST 1996
Article: 9103 of news.announce.newgroups
Path: bcm.tmc.edu!cs.utexas.edu!news.sprintlink.net!news-peer.sprintlink.net!uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Dave Cornejo)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,alt.rock-n-roll.oldies,rec.music.beatles,rec.music.misc
Subject: RESULT: rec.music.beatles.{info,moderated} moderated both pass
Supersedes: <[email protected]>
Followup-To: news.groups
Date: 31 Oct 1996 09:57:21 -0500
Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers
Lines: 506
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Message-ID: <[email protected]>
References: <[email protected]> <[email protected]>
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Archive-Name: rec.music.beatles.info
Xref: bcm.tmc.edu news.announce.newgroups:9103 news.groups:232831 alt.rock-n-roll.oldies:20197 rec.music.beatles:200410 rec.music.misc:193081
RESULT
moderated group rec.music.beatles.info passes 258:34
moderated group rec.music.beatles.moderated passes 270:45
Yes No | 2/3 >100 | Pass | Group
---- ---- | --- ---- | ---- | -------------------------------------------
258 34 | Yes Yes | Yes | rec.music.beatles.info
270 45 | Yes Yes | Yes | rec.music.beatles.moderated
5 invalid ballots
A five day discussion period follows this announcement. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the
moderator of news.announce.newgroups will create the groups shortly
thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
rec.music.beatles.info Latest press notes about the Beatles. (Moderated)
rec.music.beatles.moderated Fab Four analytical & investigative articles. (Moderated)
Voting closed at 23:59:59 UTC, 30 Oct 1996.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions
about this proposal should be directed to the proponent.
Proponent: D. L. MacLaughlan
Proponent: Maurizio Codogno
Proponent: Edward S. Chen
Proponent: Stephen D. Carter
Proponent: Joseph Brennan
Proponent: Bruce Dumes
Proponent: Allan Kozinn
Proponent: Neal Katz
Mentor: Johnathan Grobe
Votetaker: Dave Cornejo
RATIONALE: rec.music.beatles.info
With the release of archival music and documentaries on the Beatles,
plus a resurgence of interest in their music, interaction in
rec.music.beatles increased to often-unmanageable levels (300+ posts
per day). Readers using limited ISP resources can be overwhelmed when
postings reach this level. Finding concrete information amidst the
plethora of posts is not merely daunting...it can be an unmanageable
task. Following the lead of other newsgroups in similar situations,
it's been proposed that two new moderated groups be added to the
rec.music.beatles hierarchy: rec.music.beatles.info, for brief press
releases and news; and rec.music.beatles.moderated, for more in-depth
investigation and discussion. Rec.music.beatles itself would remain
intact and unchanged. There is a long-standing Usenet precedent for a
1 --> 3 evolution from one original newsgroup to the "triplex" format,
and this proposal is based on that structure. Also, for the ease of
those whose providers do not add in new rec* newsgroups and for those
whose costs would increase to download multiple groups, all postings
published in the moderated groups would be crossposted to
rec.music.beatles.
RATIONALE: rec.music.beatles.moderated
With the release of archival music and documentaries on the Beatles,
plus a resurgence of interest in their music, interaction in
rec.music.beatles increased to often-unmanageable levels (300+ posts
per day). Readers using limited ISP resources can be overwhelmed when
postings reach this level. Finding concrete information amidst the
plethora of posts is not merely daunting...it can be an unmanageable
task. Following the lead of other newsgroups in similar situations,
it's been proposed that two new moderated groups be added to the
rec.music.beatles hierarchy: rec.music.beatles.info, for brief press
releases and news; and rec.music.beatles.moderated, for more in-depth
investigation and discussion. Rec.music.beatles itself would remain
intact and unchanged. There is a long-standing Usenet precedent for a
1 --> 3 evolution from one original newsgroup to the "triplex" format,
and this proposal is based on that structure. Also, for the ease of
those whose providers do not add in new rec* newsgroups and for those
whose costs would increase to download multiple groups, all postings
published in the moderated groups would be crossposted to
rec.music.beatles.
CHARTER: rec.music.beatles.info
Rec.music.beatles.info is a moderated group of low traffic, carrying
press reports and news releases relating to the Beatles' music and the
artists' lives. Information about new audio and video releases, as
well as book and article publication, will be found here.
Articles posted to rec.music.beatles.info will be automatically
crossposted to rec.music.beatles (unmoderated) for discussion.
Moderation policy:
This group will be moderated by committee. Articles rejected from
this forum will be returned to the writer with suggestions to submit
to rec.music.beatles.moderated (if appropriate) or to
rec.music.beatles.
END CHARTER.
CHARTER: rec.music.beatles.moderated
Rec.music.beatles.moderated is a group for in-depth investigative and
analytical exploration of the Fabs' music and cultural environment.
New or amended answers which may become incorporated into FAQs will be
published here, as well as reviews and critiques about the Beatles,
their work, and their lives. Also included will be concert and
musical reviews.
Articles posted to rec.music.beatles.moderated will automatically be
crossposted to rec.music.beatles. Articles rejected from
rec.music.beatles.moderated will be returned to the writer with
suggestions for a more appropriate forum.
Moderation policy:
This group will be moderated by committee. Articles accepted for this
forum will also be crossposted to rec.music.beatles. Posters will be
notified of this fact, and allowed to withdraw their submissions if
they do not agree with this policy.
To increase the uniqueness of this group, and decrease administrative
hassles, all articles crossposted by the user will be automatically
rejected.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: rec.music.beatles.info
Moderator: Maurizio Codogno
Moderator: "Edward S. Chen"
Moderator: "D. L. MacLaughlan"
Moderator: Neal Katz
Moderator: Bruce Dumes
Administrative contact address: [email protected]
Article submission address: [email protected]
END MODERATOR INFO.
MODERATOR INFO: rec.music.beatles.moderated
Moderator: Maurizio Codogno
Moderator: "Edward S. Chen"
Moderator: "D. L. MacLaughlan"
Moderator: Neal Katz
Moderator: Bruce Dumes
Administrative contact address: [email protected]
Article submission address: [email protected]
END MODERATOR INFO.
DISTRIBUTION:
This CFV has been cross-posted to:
alt.rock-n-roll.oldies
rec.music.beatles
rec.music.info
rec.music.misc
rec.music.beatles.{info,moderated} Final Voter list
rec.music.beatles.moderated ----+
rec.music.beatles.info ---+|
||
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected] Mark Jeffery YY
[email protected] Andrew John Walker YY
[email protected] Y-
[email protected] Matthew Jackson YY
[email protected] Kees van de Wetering Y-
[email protected] YY
[email protected] Rob YY
[email protected] Ian Strung NN
[email protected] Robert A. G. Seely YY
[email protected] Martin Grant YY
[email protected] Frank Hayes YY
[email protected] David Walker YY
[email protected] peter (p.) mitchell NY
[email protected] Rich Karfilis YY
[email protected] Brian Edmonds NN
[email protected] De Repentigny Yves YY
[email protected] J Rufinus YY
[email protected] Ryszard Gokieli YY
[email protected] Christoph Maeder YY
[email protected] Keith E. Jackson YY
[email protected] Ethel Kerr YY
[email protected] Jeff Kerr YY
[email protected] Jim Richard YY
[email protected] ziggy YY
[email protected] YN
[email protected] Cami Lee YY
[email protected] steve iverson YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] YN
[email protected] Y-
[email protected] YY
[email protected] -Y
[email protected] -Y
[email protected] -Y
[email protected] YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] -Y
[email protected] YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] -Y
[email protected] YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] YN
[email protected] YN
[email protected] -Y
[email protected] YY
[email protected] Jim Vegeais YY
[email protected] Dan Van Vugt YY
[email protected] Steve Fenster YY
[email protected] Antoinette E Sasso YY
[email protected] Bob Clements YY
[email protected] Steve Marinucci YY
[email protected] Dwight Brown NN
[email protected] Cathy YY
[email protected] Harrison Sherwood -Y
[email protected] Brian J. Ferguson YY
[email protected] Brett Pasternack YN
[email protected] ANSSI IIVARI YY
[email protected] Tom Lowry YY
[email protected] Martin H. Booda NN
[email protected] Jay Smith YY
[email protected] Tina Mohamad NN
[email protected] Larie YY
[email protected] Charles E. Moore YY
[email protected] Jennifer DeBernardis YY
[email protected] Kathy Umholtz YY
[email protected] Alburger YY
[email protected] Tansal YY
[email protected] Haviv Rettig -Y
[email protected] J. Kenneth Burton YY
[email protected] Jim Riley -N
[email protected] semdad -Y
[email protected] Bruce Dumes YY
[email protected] Natalie Ramsey -N
[email protected] Nick Ingegneri NN
[email protected] YY
[email protected] Dominik Halas YY
[email protected] Sooz YY
[email protected] Kent Stewart YY
[email protected] David Fell YY
[email protected] john calabro YY
[email protected] Saul H Hiller -Y
[email protected] LIZ G THOMPSON -Y
[email protected] Javier Henderson YY
[email protected] Jim Casaburi YY
[email protected] Richard W. Cook YY
[email protected] ray kelly -Y
[email protected] Fan Yeng Loon (Cybermedia) YY
[email protected] d-max YY
[email protected] Chris P. Mezzolesta YY
[email protected] d. -Y
[email protected] Rich Baranowski YY
[email protected] Ronnie Grant YY
[email protected] Paul Maclauchlan YY
[email protected] Hank Hayes YN
[email protected] Marc Wielage YY
[email protected] Olav Nieuwejaar NN
[email protected] Higher.Level.Productions YY
[email protected] Rick Schubert YY
[email protected] Alan Cooper YY
[email protected] Andres Torres YY
[email protected] J. Bovine YY
[email protected] Davo9 YY
[email protected] Ed Igoe YY
[email protected] Jon Campbell -Y
[email protected] Jim Lowman -N
[email protected] Joseph Anthony Calderaio -Y
[email protected] Bill Synnamon YY
[email protected] Walter Wilde YY
[email protected] Joe Morris YY
[email protected] Jai Young Kim YY
[email protected] Keith Jaskiewicz -N
[email protected] Kim DeVaughn YY
[email protected] Jon Noring NN
[email protected] Joe Caldwell Y-
[email protected] YY
[email protected] -Y
[email protected] Susan Wasserman YY
[email protected] Ashok Katwala YY
[email protected] Dave Haber YY
[email protected] The One And Only YY
[email protected] MS LEE PHENNER -Y
[email protected] Robert Mcfarland YY
[email protected] Mark Rubenstein YY
[email protected] Rick Holland YY
[email protected] Jane Woo YY
[email protected] Joe Bernstein NN
[email protected] Stephanie Bradley YY
[email protected] Scott Jennings YY
[email protected] Mike Cohen NN
[email protected] Charles G. Hill YY
[email protected] Chris Stamper NN
[email protected] Bus error - core dumped NN
[email protected] Marc Dashevsky YY
[email protected] Duane Day YY
[email protected] Jim Kendall -Y
[email protected] Pan YY
[email protected] David M. Putzolu -N
[email protected] Michael D. Smith YY
[email protected] chris YY
[email protected] Mike Goodrum YY
[email protected] Marcia J. Lebron Scanner N-
[email protected] Bob Bowen YY
[email protected] StevenX YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] Dave Montuori YY
[email protected] STEVE BENSON YY
[email protected] Sascha Wildner YY
[email protected] Bart De Pontieu YY
[email protected] Martin Schr"oder YN
[email protected] Ralph Weigmann YY
[email protected] Steffen.Vogler YY
[email protected] Wolf-Ruediger.Schneider YY
[email protected] lantony -Y
[email protected] Lars Bendix Y-
[email protected] Ole M. Nielsen YY
[email protected] Joe Mason YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] David W. Crawford YY
[email protected] Mark Fonnemann YN
[email protected] Karl Johnsen YY
[email protected] Robert Craig Harman NN
[email protected] YY
[email protected] Joe Brennan YY
[email protected] Ken at Lehman Library YY
[email protected] Michael Fornabaio YY
[email protected] Morgen LeFaye Hughes YY
[email protected] Rob Hughes YY
[email protected] David Faciane YY
[email protected] Mac (James) Baker YY
[email protected] robert young YY
[email protected] Raymond Arritt YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] David Shaw YY
[email protected] Stephen Philip Karsch YY
[email protected] David J. Beedle YY
[email protected] Mike Mihalus YY
[email protected] Deb Ott YY
[email protected] Jennifer White YY
[email protected] Bill Hess YY
[email protected] Bradley Keith Adams -Y
[email protected] Drew Patterson YY
[email protected] Christopher B. Stone NN
[email protected] Ron Crandall YY
[email protected] Sue Dolan YY
[email protected] Jonas Karlsson YY
[email protected] Gordon Thompson YY
[email protected] Russ Allbery YY
[email protected] Robert Allan Hedges YY
[email protected] Joshua Kramer YY
[email protected] Sandra L. McMurtry YY
[email protected] Harley Gorrell YY
[email protected] Richard H. Miller YN
[email protected] Ganapathiraju Sree Ramana Gopal NN
[email protected] Alexander Gusakov YY
[email protected] Marc M. Darr YY
[email protected] FLORENCIO UMEL JR. YY
[email protected] Gerald F. Kominski, Ph.D. YY
[email protected] D.L. MACLAUGHLAN YY
[email protected] NN
[email protected] Brian Geiger YY
[email protected] Ramin Homayouni YY
[email protected] Edward S. Chen YY
[email protected] kimberly j. sham YY
[email protected] Aaron Schab YY
[email protected] Mark Tomas YY
[email protected] Michael T Pins NN
[email protected] Jim Wong NY
[email protected] Jaisri Gangadhaan NN
[email protected] David Lott YY
[email protected] Paramasivam NN
[email protected] Chris Phillips NN
[email protected] John W. Hazelton YY
[email protected] Nicole Nims YY
[email protected]
Jonathan Young [correct e-mail address at end of message] YY
[email protected] Sarah Jones YY
[email protected] Maurizio Oliva YY
[email protected] B. Pham YY
[email protected] Benjamin Lukoff YY
[email protected] Gus Lopez YN
[email protected] M. Shock YY
[email protected] R.Bull/B.Bauer YY
[email protected] Jennifer Darling YY
[email protected] Enrique Cabrera Rochera YY
[email protected] Ari-Pekka Sihvonen YY
[email protected] Aaro Koskinen NN
[email protected] Kimmo Ketolainen +358 40 555 5508 YY
[email protected] Ollivier Robert -Y
[email protected] Richard Eckman YY
[email protected] J. Porter Clark YY
[email protected] Jon Roe YY
[email protected] Vice Sunjara YY
[email protected] Rafael Gafoor Y-
[email protected] Leonid Revzin YY
[email protected] yarden uriel YY
[email protected] Bluebird YY
[email protected] John Sinclair YY
[email protected] Vittorio Curtoni YY
[email protected] Dona Y-
[email protected] Maurizio Codogno YY
[email protected] Marco Mesturino YY
[email protected] Ugo Allisiardi YY
[email protected] Gino Lucrezi YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] Bruce C Goettel YY
[email protected] Frank Kennedy YY
[email protected] David N. Barnett -Y
[email protected] Bud Loveall YY
[email protected] K. Wise YY
[email protected] LiveLetDie YY
[email protected] Sean Lamb YY
[email protected] Tom Sella YY
[email protected] Herbert Han-pu Wang YY
[email protected] Mark and Carol Tomas YY
[email protected] morethanone kalar YY
[email protected] Paxil YY
[email protected] Michael Yeoman YY
[email protected] Kevin Gilhooly YY
[email protected] Pat Lillge YY
[email protected] Roger K Adams -Y
[email protected] Susan Juliano YY
[email protected] Geert van der Veen NN
[email protected] Tom Hartman YY
[email protected] M Patterson YY
[email protected] Jules Dubois YY
[email protected] Jeffrey YY
[email protected] Ayn Shipley YY
[email protected] Jenna YY
[email protected] Charles Oliver NN
[email protected] David Goodwin YY
[email protected] Michael W./Lee Ann Foley YY
[email protected] Will Hancock YY
[email protected] Meg YY
[email protected] Dennis McGee YY
[email protected] Robert Stahley YY
[email protected] Joey Self YY
[email protected] Marsha Hunt YY
[email protected] Kenn Knowlton YY
[email protected] DJMc YY
[email protected] Charles C Baker YY
[email protected] lynn harvey YY
[email protected] JoE Silva YY
[email protected] Brad Lander -Y
[email protected] C. B. "Kit" Gerhart -Y
[email protected] Joerg Berger NN
[email protected] Shrisha Rao NN
[email protected] Edward Ripple Jr. YY
[email protected] Tim Gerdes YY
[email protected] Paul Roub YY
[email protected] Dan LaMee YY
[email protected] superfly -Y
[email protected] Brian Bresnahan YY
[email protected] Stuman_ YY
[email protected] A. Bergsma NN
[email protected] Domenico Giunta YY
[email protected] J.J. Pierens YY
[email protected] Peter van Schie YY
[email protected] Johan Schadee NN
[email protected] Stuart Yeates YY
[email protected] MIZ YY
[email protected] Simon Lyall NN
[email protected] David L. Hanson NN
[email protected] Robert Triptow YY
[email protected] B Serviss N-
[email protected] John Watson YY
[email protected] Paolo Pellegrino YY
[email protected] Michael Nordstrom YY
[email protected] Stefan Ventura� YY
[email protected] Rolf Olsson -Y
[email protected] M.S. Robb YY
[email protected] R.N. Weinstein YY
[email protected] Andy Cross YY
[email protected] Richard Green YY
[email protected] Stephen Carter YY
[email protected] Nick Waterman NN
[email protected] Nickey Davies YY
[email protected] Tony Corless YY
[email protected] Liz Prigg YY
[email protected] Mike YY
[email protected] Tony Quinn YY
[email protected] Transplanted Montanan YY
[email protected] YY
[email protected] Chris Schram YY
Invalid ballots
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected] Centre Environnement - ULG
! Invalid address
[email protected] Peter Cipriano
! No vote statement in message
[email protected] Sustaita Juan A
! No vote statement in message
[email protected] Dennis McWhinnie
! No vote statement in message
[email protected]
! No vote statement in message
