Notes on "Dig It" (DI)

KEY	F Major

METER 3/4 (surprise!)

FORM (fade in) Refrain -> Refrain' -> Refrain''... (fade out) + spoken bit

GENERAL POINTS OF INTEREST


Style and Form

- Given the sometimes seemingly endless hours and even days on end of the Beatles drifting out of one loosely coupled but extended jam session into another during the Get Back month of January '69, our snippet of a song here, "Dig It (DI)," would appear to bear an unfair and awesome burden, serving as the sole remnant of such musical horseplay to make the cut for the official LIB album.

- But DI also demonstrates once again how even humblest of Beatles recordings bears examination and provokes thought. No matter that the specific musical content here is arguably slight. It's the exploitation of the recorded medium for its own sake that creates value in this case. And more irony: it doesn't really matter if it was genuinely Phil Spector's own idea to handle it in this manner. The upside credit for just about anything good on the LIB album acrues to the group themselves, with Spector left holding the bag for what's wrong with it. So much for the Beatles as nature intended.

- The official release of this song on the _Let It Be_ album is a scant minute-long choice cut excerpted from a much longer performance of it in the studio, with a spoken bit from an entirely different arrangement of the same number tacked on to the ending. This simple yet deft act of audio retouching uncannily elevates an otherwise half baked, improvisationally executed idea (as evidenced by the film clips and unedited audio tape) into a recorded "gesture," at once both inspired for wild zaniness and presciently apt in the way it sets up Paul's big anthem which follows. But no offence intended: anyone who has ever goofily jammed with friends at a home party must listen to this track and think on some level, "gee, I can do just as well as this."

- In spite of its comparable brevity, DI's gesture should not be confused with what I've described elsewhere as the complete-but-miniature "bonsai song form;" see Notes on "Wild Honey Pie" and "... In the Road." DI is different, both in its circular, undifferentiated form, and the extent to which the fade-in tips you off that what you're listening to is taken out of context from something much longer. Actually, the circular form only goes to add to the illusion of open ended duration.


Melody and Harmony

- The tune is rivited around the tonic note of the home key in the manner of the talking blues style, but there are also noticeable flashes of the bluesy flat 3rd and flat 7th scale degrees.

- The chords are your old, elementary friends: I, IV, and V.


Arrangement

- The backing track is a muddy kitchen sink kind of production with organ, piano, and drums playing prominent roles.

- The backbeat of the complete performance of DI varies over the long run, but our excerpt for the official release is clearly in a syncopated 3/4.

SECTION-BY-SECTION WALKTHROUGH


Refrain

- The entire musical fabric is based on a simple four measure pattern which I believe tends to repeat itself in pairs:

        --------------- 2X --------------
        |F	|Bb	|C	|Bb	|

F:	 I	 IV	 V	 IV

Spoken Bit

- John's falsetto spoken bit is neatly (and not at all randomly) spliced in so that the start of it overlaps with the fadeout of the base track, but with the ending of it left fully exposed.

SOME FINAL THOUGHTS

- The carefully cropped and retouched fragment of DI on the LIB album presents the song as if it were something that is all John's, and John's only. I believe this is a distortian of reality, but you need to hear the complete recording and its associated alternates to get the broader perspective.

- I trace the origin of the song to at least as far back to the 1/9 session at Twickenham where the infamous "Commonwealth Song" is followed by another improvisation entitled "Get Off!" The latter features John and Paul antiphonally shouting a free association stream of people's names (some obscure as well as those of celebrities) over a 12-bar blues vamp, and the frequent refraining phrase, "can you dig it?"

- The rest of the extant performances are from the sessions at Apple. 1/24 is the date of what you might call the the pair of "spastic" versions of the song in which the arrangement is characterized by comically sloppy slide guitar work and an equally unreliable tempo. The vamp is still 12-bar, and John and Paul continue to spar verbally with wicked case of the sillies. The second take from this day has a complete ending built out of the classically Beatlesque gambit of three-times-you're-out.

- The ending of this take also happens to be from where "Hark the angels" comes from, though you need to check two bootlegs (SFTP volumes 1 and 2) in order to hear the entire thing. Trailing the spoken bit you're familiar with, John, on the source tape, actually mock sings a line of "Hark ..."

- 1/26 is the date on which the official recording was made. The longest excerpt of this unofficially available grinds on for 8:23 with the following points of interest:

- The LIB album version of ~50 seconds is taken from around minute 5, with the 1/24 spoken bit tacked on. The version slated for the _Get Back_ album is ~4 minutes in length and contains roughly the second half of the 8 minute recording. It also has the same partial spoken bit spliced in which is followed by a final plagal cadence for the backing ensemble that is not part of the 8:23 tape. There's even a video excerpt of this performance in the LIB film, showing the four Beatles, plus Yoko, Billy Preston, Heather Eastman, and George Martin (shaking a Latin percussion instrument).

- Reportedly there's 33 seconds worth of an outtake from 1/27 that I haven't heard. Any takers out there? And finally, there's part of a very fast version in 12/8 rhythm recorded on 1/29, featuring Paul with a doo-wop, woah-woah-woah backing vocal.

- The alternates, even the parts of the official take that were edited out, suggest a level of byplay between John and Paul (and even George) that belies the John-only vision suggested by the official track. While DI may have been inspired and even loosely "composed & conducted" by John, I think the full set of outtakes provides a rare but by no means unique counter example to the conventional portrayal of the group at this point as supposedly being incapable of having a good time out together.

Regards,

Alan (awp@world.std.com)

---
"Saint Buttersfield Cargo..."                                080199#171
---



                Copyright (c) 1999 by Alan W. Pollack
                          All Rights Reserved
This article may be reproduced, retransmitted, redistributed and otherwise propagated at will, provided that this notice remains intact and in place.
Click here to return.

Click here to return to AWP's index.